Estate Street Partners-Top Irrevocable Trust Asset Protection
A rating from BBB (Better Business Bureau) for Ultra Trust irrevoable trust.

Roth 401k vs Traditional

Compare Return of Investment of
Roth 401(k) to traditional 401(k)

Call Rocco Beatrice Now-Irrevocable Trust Asset Protection Expert
Home | What's a Trust? | What's Estate Tax? | What's Probate? | Financial Grid | Lawsuits | Elder Care
Comparing the Roth 401(k) and the traditional 401(k) is analyzed. A new retirement plan, known as the Roth 401(k), can provide financial benefits for almost every individual entering retirement. By using this plan, retirees will receive the maximum amount annually from their funded account. In addition, the distributions will be tax-free and will exceed the amount that would be received if the client were using a traditional 401(k).

Roth 401(k) Plans

In 2006, an innovative retirement account was introduced. This new cutting-edge plan is a derivative of the traditional 401(k) plan we all know so well. There is one major difference that sets this new Roth 401(k) account apart from the traditional 401(k). With a Roth 401(k), the entire funding of the plan will be done with money after taxes have been paid. This does make it very similar to a Roth IRA, however, the Roth 401(k) will have contribution limits. There are no income limits placed on contributions to the account. All funds that are placed into a Roth 401(k) will continue to mature in the account without any taxes and the funds are later distributed to the account holder with no taxes. The contribution limit of the account as of 2007 was $15,500 is $16,500 annually and $25,500 $22,000 for anyone over the age of 50.

Roth 401(k) return of investment

The Roth 401(k) plan may not be the best financial decision for all people, however, if you will be retiring and remaining in the same, or moving to a higher tax bracket, or you will be entering retirement with a margin of 10% of your current tax bracket, the Roth 401(k) plan might be the right choice for your situation.

Illustrating an example to determine when a Roth 401(k) would be beneficial. Mr. Gruber is in currently in the 40% bracket. When he retires, he will be in the 30% bracket, a reduction of 10%. In this case, the use of a Roth 401(k) would be a financially sound decision. In this illustration, Mr. Gruber is a 40 year old who is funding $16,000 into a Roth 401(k) plan. He will fund for a period of 25 years and when he enters retirement, he can take tax-free distributions when he is between the ages of 66 and 85. Since the funding that is being made is not deductible to the plan, the individual will have to pay taxes based on the funding since the funds are paid after taxes. The taxes to be paid are as follows:

  • 40% bracket will require $6,400 in taxes
  • 30% bracket will require $4,800 in taxes
  • 15% bracket will require $2,400 in taxes

In this instance, we will presume that there is an average 7% rate of return for the course of the Roth 401(k) plan.

Traditional 401(k) Plan vs Roth 401(k) Plan

To create a matching illustration with investments to a traditional 401(k) plan, the individual will have to invest a certain amount of money that will equal the taxes that would have been saved if they were using a traditional 401(k) plan (as opposed to the investments of the Roth 401(k) plan). The money that would have been saved is as follows:

  • $6,400 in tax savings in the 40% bracket
  • $4,800 in tax savings in the 30% bracket
  • $2,400 in tax savings in the 15% bracket

In reality, we need to consider the investment in an after-tax stock market with actual numbers. These numbers should always include the tax on capital gains as well as dividends and after the taxes are paid from the broker account. The numbers below are based on the taxes that are due on the annual growth in the account.

  • 25% if in the individual is in the 40% bracket
  • 20% if in the individual is in the 30% bracket
  • 15% if in the individual is in the 15% bracket

What is the amount that can be received in retirement from the Roth 401(k) plan?

The return of investment of the Roth 401(k)

Between the ages of 66 to 85, the individual would receive $65,364 from the plan annually. This income received would be tax free.

In comparison, what is the amount if the individual used a traditional, taxable (upon withdrawal) 401(k)?

The return of investment of the Traditional 401(k)

  • if the individual were in the 40% tax bracket, the amount would be $41,325
  • if the individual were in the 30% tax bracket, the amount would be $46,348
  • if in the individual were in the 15% tax bracket, the amount would be $55,045

These numbers that are provided above will have to be in addition to the extra side account. This extra account would be contributed with the extra money that would be in possession after funding a traditional 401(k) plan that is deductible. Recall the traditional 401(k) plan is made with contributions before taxes. In other words, the contributions that were made were tax deductible. From this account, the individual would then receive the following amounts when they enter retirement:

  • $17,759 in the 40% bracket
  • $15,591 in the 30% bracket
  • $10,861 in the 15% bracket

So we now add the last two sets of numbers, based on the fact that the individual has a regular 401(k) and an extra side account:

  • $59,084 if the individual is in a tax bracket of 40%
  • $61,939 if the individual is in a tax bracket of 30%
  • $65,906 if the individual is in a tax bracket of 15%

These numbers clearly show that the Roth 401(k) will provide more retirement income that the traditional 401(k), no matter what the tax bracket is.

If the tax brackets change in retirement for the Roth 401(k) plan

Let'ís take a look at the situation if the individual begins in a 40% bracket and then reduces to a 30% tax bracket when he retires. In this case, the client would be able to remove $66,322 annually. If the numbers dropped from 30% to 15%, the client would get $69,123. If the tax bracket went from 30% to 40%, the result would be $54,119 and if the tax bracket was 40% and went to 15%, the amount would equal $76,550.

The Roth 401(k) plan is a good choice for almost any individual as you can observe by the returns. Businesses should consider the Roth 401(k) for their employees.

Contact Estate Street Partners to discuss how we can help you in your Roth 401(k) planning. Estate Street Partners offers advanced asset protection strategies utilizing our premium Ultra Trust® irrevocable trust for transferring your assets to your beneficiaries.

Read about Captive Insurance Company Plans

About the Ultra Trust®:

Read more articles on irrevocable trust asset protection:

To learn more about irrevocable trusts and senior elder care visit:

UltraTrust home | Sitemap

Irrevocable Trust Asset Protection customer testmonials.
Irrevocable Trust Asset Protection book reviews.
Sign up for a FREE newsletter to learn about the latest inside secrets to wealth-building, tax-saving tips and strategies for your successful financial roadmap...PLUS you'll receive a FREE downloadable eBook on precisely how the surefire Ultra Trust® - the Irrevocable Trust Asset Protection program developed by an Award-Winning Estate Planner - can save you thousands of dollars of legal fees; save you hundreds of hours of your valuable time; reduce your taxes completely legally; secure your privacy, preserve your money and protect your assets in one easy, fast step-by-step plan...

* required



We never share your email information with third parties. We collect your email address so you can benefit from money-saving tips. For more information please review our privacy policy. Powered by VerticalResponse